I mentioned in my last post that I would talk about a little girl named Effie Spangle who was buried in the Hamilton Cemetery in Otsego Township in Steuben County, Indiana. She is buried next to Susannah (Crago) Browning, wife of Absalom Browning. A few stones over are buried Susannah's daughter Sarah Margaret Spangle and two of the three children that Sarah Margaret's had (Franklin and little Belle) with her husband Lafayette Spangle.
Effie intrigues me. She's a question mark. No matter how hard I try I can't put her in this family. Follow along with me and I think you'll see what I mean.
Take a look at the picture to the right. It shows the burial locations of all the people I'm discussing here; I've labeled them for easy reference.
Sarah Margaret Browning married Lafayette Spangle on 24 Jul 1869 in Steuben County. The couple had three known children (Franklin b. Aug 1870, Sarah M. b. Aug 1871, and Belle b. Nov 1872) before Sarah died a week after she gave birth to Belle.
Sarah was buried first and when little Belle died in early 1873 she was buried to the left of her mother's stone. When Franklin died four years later (in 1877) he was buried on his mother's other side.
Then there was a lapse in burials until Susannah (Crago) Browning died in 1890. Hers is the largest stone in the background of the picture. But as you can see, there's a small stone to the right of Susannah's stone....that's Effie. But who was she?
However, there was a cemetery transcription book available that was read some years ago and in it, the inscription is said to read,
"Effie L Spangle D. May 28, 1867 Age 1y. 10m. 9d. Dau of S. M. Spangle"
I don't know about that at all. To me it looks more like:
"Effie L., dau of LJ & S Spangle died May 28, 1867 aged 1y. 10m. 19d."
I'm not at all sure that it's LJ & S. Maybe it's LJ & SM. Or L & M. Or none of those! Argh!!
The date of death, however, is clear. 28 May. The year? I can't read it. It "looks" like 186....something. But here's the thing. If it is 1867 then whose daughter is this little girl? Lafayette and Sarah weren't married until 1869. And if it's 1877 then that's equally bad, as Sarah was dead in 1872. Perhaps it's 1871 and this little girl is Sarah's twin? Or perhaps it is 1869 and Sarah Margaret Browning was pregnant before she and Lafayette got married? Or perhaps the original reader was right and it's 1867 and wow, she was pregnant two years before she got married?
You got me. Effie's buried next to all the Spangles is all that I know for sure. Someday, maybe, if I ever get to Steuben County, I can go see for myself. I'd love to see what you all think.
5 hours ago